The lawsuit that made a band the villain

In April 2000, Metallica sued Napster for copyright infringement.[2] Napster was a file sharing service, which means people copied songs straight from each other’s computers.[1] The band turned in a list of 335,435 Napster users it said were sharing its songs, printed on about 60,000 pages.[2]

In March 2001 the judge ordered Napster to stop sharing the band’s music while the case went on.[2] Napster shut down in July 2001, settled with Metallica the next day,[3] and filed for bankruptcy in 2002.[4]

Why so many fans turned on them

A lot of listeners took the lawsuit personally. I was one of them. I thought the band had declared war on its own audience, and I was not shy about saying so.

I was wrong. The band was asking a company to stop copying its work without permission. Kirk Hammett, the band’s guitarist, said in 2018 that they were still right about Napster.[5]

A smaller band says the same thing happened to it

In July 2025, Pixel Grip, a band from Chicago, said that Travis Scott used part of their 2021 song “Pursuit” on his song “Kick Out” without asking, crediting or paying them.[6][7] Taking a piece of an existing recording and putting it in a new song is called sampling.

That is their accusation. It is not a court ruling. After their post spread, a producer on the track messaged the band that the label should be reaching out to clear the sample.[6] The band said they like the song but felt hurt about not getting credit.[8]

Artists are not open source

Open source software is code anyone may use, change and share, because its author chose to allow it. A song is not open source. Copyright gives the creator control from the moment the work exists, and permission is the rule, not the exception.

Royalties are the payments a creator gets when their work is used or sold. A cleared sample usually brings credit and money to the original artist. An uncleared one brings neither.

That is why the Metallica case still matters. Protection that only works for artists who can afford lawyers is not protection. It is a privilege. A small band needs the same rule as a famous one. That is the idea behind Napstop, a project on 5pm.io where artists and fans can report stolen work to the people who own it. It also ties to my post on Banksy, who once wrote that copyright is for losers and still guards his images.

First draft by DeepSeek (V4.1 High Flash, as Happy reported). Claude checked the facts, rewrote what did not hold up and built the page.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia, "Napster" (what Napster was and how it shared files)
  2. Wikipedia, "Metallica v. Napster, Inc." (335,435 users on a 60,000 page list; March 2001 preliminary injunction by Judge Marilyn Hall Patel; settlement July 12, 2001)
  3. Plagiarism Today, Apr 13, 2020, "20 years later: Metallica v. Napster, Inc." (Napster shut down July 11, 2001 and settled with Metallica and Dr. Dre the next day)
  4. Kerrang!, Metallica vs Napster (Napster filed for bankruptcy in 2002)
  5. NME, May 2018 (Kirk Hammett on Swedish TV show Nyhetsmorgon: the band is still right about Napster)
  6. Stereogum, July 16, 2025 (Pixel Grip said Travis Scott sampled "Pursuit" without permission on "Kick Out"; co producer Sean Momberger messaged that the label should reach out to clear the sample)
  7. The FADER, July 17, 2025 (the band says the sample was not cleared and they got no credit or payment)
  8. Wikipedia, "Kick Out" (the band said they like the song but felt hurt about not getting credit)

Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.

Next relatedMy Supreme Court QR Code vs a Banksy: Which Lasts?
Revision history (R0 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
R0Nov 19, 2026First publish. DeepSeek draft (V4.1 High Flash per Happy), fact checked and built by Claude (Opus). Fixed: the ABC News July 2000 source was about a different, earlier injunction, replaced with the March 2001 injunction in the Metallica case, the July 2001 shutdown and settlement, and the 2002 bankruptcy. The "a little exploited" quote from Resident Advisor could not be opened, so it was replaced with the band's verified line from the Kick Out article. Kirk Hammett cited to NME 2018. Checked through search results only: Wikipedia, NME, Stereogum, FADER pages were not opened in full. travisscott.com was not opened.view