The idea

Picture a place with no cell signal and no internet. Someone needs to send a payment. What if the message went out by radio, signed, so the receiver knows who sent it? A digital signature proves who sent a message. It does not hide what the message says.

A second question follows. How can many people use one radio band at the same time? The answer starts with modulation, which is how data is encoded onto a radio wave. Engineers have many techniques, and some let a lot of users share one band.

How many users can share one band

One method is CDMA. It lets several transmitters send at the same time over one channel, with each one assigned its own code.[1] Walsh codes are one set of such codes. In a CDMA system, many users share one band by being assigned orthogonal codes, such as Walsh codes.[2] Orthogonal means the codes are built so they do not interfere with each other. The whole family is called spread spectrum, because the signal is spread across a wider band than it needs.

Why ham radio is probably the wrong place

In the US, amateur radio is governed by Part 97 of the rules of the Federal Communications Commission. It bars messages encoded for the purpose of obscuring their meaning.[5] Spread spectrum carries the same limit, and the operator must keep a record that can be converted back to the original information.[3][4] A signature on its own should be fine, since the text stays in the clear. That is one ham's reading, not an FCC ruling.[7]

The bigger wall is money. The FCC says ham to ham communication is allowed unless it is specifically prohibited, done for compensation, or done for the financial benefit of the operator or the operator's employer.[6] A payment is about money. I could not find an FCC ruling on payment messages, so I cannot say for sure, but it looks like a poor fit.

What other radio already does

LoRa is a modulation derived from chirp spread spectrum. It runs on license free bands, such as 915 MHz in the US.[10] Meshtastic, a mesh network built on it, can run under Part 15 rules in that band, or under Part 97 in the amateur parts of it. Under Part 97, encryption must be turned off.[11]

People already send Bitcoin this way. A hackathon project called Darkwire lets users send Bitcoin transactions over LoRa radio where there is no internet.[12] BTC Mesh signs a transaction on an offline device, relays it across a Meshtastic mesh, and a gateway in range of the internet rebroadcasts it.[13] The limits are real. A raw Bitcoin transaction can run 200 to 500 bytes or more, so it gets split into fragments.[13] LoRa has very limited range and bandwidth.[14]

Robots that keep their targets secret

Happy had a second use in mind. Picture autonomous robots searching for gold, sending each other where to dig. Someone could listen in and learn the targets. The fix is encryption, not a signature. Encryption scrambles a message so only the intended receiver can read it. In practice RSA is used to swap a secret key, and a faster cipher then protects the stream.

Ham radio bans this, as covered above. A license free band is different. Meshtastic ships with encryption on, and the rule to switch it off applies only when you transmit under Part 97.[11] So in the US, a robot fleet on a license free band such as 915 MHz could encrypt its target messages without a ham license. Other countries set their own rules, and I did not check any of them. Ignoring a radio rule is a risk to your license, your gear and your legal standing, so check the rules where the robots will actually work.

What would have to change

For ham radio in the US, three things: an exception to the financial interest rule for payments, a clear statement that signatures do not obscure meaning, and room for the spreading codes. None looks likely soon. The FCC dismissed a 2013 petition to change Section 97.113.[5] ARRL opposed a petition that wanted the encoded message rule read more strictly.[8] Other countries differ, and the international rules bar encoding between stations of different countries for the purpose of obscuring meaning.[9]

For license free bands, little has to change, because the pieces already work. What is missing is a standard way to sign a small payment, a way for many gateways to accept it, and someone to run those gateways.

Where this stops

These are US rules as of November 18, 2026, and rules can change. This is not legal advice, and I am not a lawyer. Payments over radio is an idea with early demos, not a finished system. A signature proves who sent a message. It does not make the message secret. Check your own country's rules before you transmit anything. For how a wallet signs, see Your Wallet Is Your Signature. For a login built the same way, see Sign In With a Wallet, Delivered Over SimpleX. For the cell side of leaving a plan, see Do You Still Need a Cell Plan When Wi-Fi Is Everywhere?

Sources

  1. Wikipedia, Code division multiple access (several transmitters send at once over one channel, each assigned a code)
  2. US Patent 6134215, Using orthogonal waveforms to enable multiple transmitters to share a single CDM channel (users share a CDMA band through orthogonal codes such as Walsh codes)
  3. Cornell Legal Information Institute, 47 CFR 97.311, SS emission types (spread spectrum must not be used to obscure meaning)
  4. 47 CFR 97.311 as of 2020 (the licensee must keep a record convertible to the original information)
  5. FCC, DA 13 1918, order dismissing a petition to change Section 97.113 (2013)
  6. FCC, Amateur radio service FAQ on appropriate communications (compensation and pecuniary benefit limits)
  7. Bruce Perens, Yes, It Is Legal To Use Cryptographic Signature on Amateur Radio (one ham's reading, not an FCC ruling)
  8. ARRL, ARRL asks FCC to dismiss petition seeking declaratory ruling on encoded message rule
  9. Federal Register, Amateur Service Rules (May 3, 2006; quotes the international rule against encoding to obscure meaning between countries)
  10. W1BAA, Meshtastic (LoRa derived from chirp spread spectrum; license free bands such as 915 MHz)
  11. Meshtastic introduction (Part 15 in the 902 to 928 MHz band, or Part 97 in the amateur portions; encryption must be off under Part 97)
  12. Decrypt, This Project Lets You Send Bitcoin Without Internet Access (Darkwire)
  13. D-Central, Bitcoin over Meshtastic (BTC Mesh signs a transaction offline, relays it over a LoRa mesh, a gateway rebroadcasts it)
  14. 63 Sats, Bitcoin beyond the internet (LoRa has very limited range and bandwidth)

Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.

Next relatedSign In With a Wallet, Delivered Over SimpleX: A Better 2FA Idea
Revision history (R0 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
R0Nov 18, 2026First published. Written by Claude (Sonnet) from Kenny's idea and steering in chat, not DeepSeek. Facts were checked against the fourteen pages listed. The financial interest rule is described through the FCC's own FAQ; no FCC ruling on payment messages was found. Whether Walsh codes are allowed under the current spread spectrum text was NOT confirmed. Rule pages were read through search results, not the current eCFR text, so check Part 97 directly. This is a judgment heavy post, so a second look on Opus is worth it. Wikipedia links are from memory.view