The Bidet Act: a tax credit for clean butts
Americans flush about 141 rolls of toilet paper a person a year, and the sewers choke on wipes. A small tax credit for a bidet seat fixes both. Here is the math, the proposal and how to put one on.
We cut down forests to wipe our asses. A cheap bidet says that's stupid.
Every toilet in my house has a bidet seat on it. Every single one. Putting one on takes me 10 to 15 minutes, and most of that is finding the towel. I'm not rich and I'm not fancy. I'm an engineer who got tired of buying a product made from trees, used for three seconds, and then flushed into a sewer that wasn't built for it.
So here's my pitch. A small tax credit, federal or Illinois, for putting a bidet on a toilet. Call it the Bidet Act. And a second idea for the trades: the plumbers' bidet special. Numbers first, opinions after. Check me.
The load we're carrying
Rolls. The usual figure is that Americans use about 141 rolls of toilet paper per person per year, the most in the world, ahead of Germany at 134 and the UK at 127.[1][2] Keep me honest here: that number gets challenged. One critique points out it comes from a weight estimate (about 12.7 kg per person per year) and depends on what you call a "roll",[3] and some stat sites use 100 rolls instead.[4] I'll use 141 because it's the most cited, and I'll show the math so you can swap in your own.
Trees. One tree makes roughly 1,500 rolls, which works out to over 31 million trees a year just for US toilet paper.[5] Most major US brands rely on wood from the Canadian boreal forest,[5] and logging there claims more than a million acres a year, partly to feed US tissue demand.[1] NRDC says the companies behind almost 80% of US toilet paper use virgin pulp, not recycled.[6]
Water and power per roll. The famous figure is 37 gallons of water, 1.3 kWh of electricity and about 1.5 pounds of wood per roll, reported by Treehugger and repeated by Scientific American.[7] Here's where I keep myself honest again. Other estimates land much lower: Bidet.org gives a range of 12 to 37 gallons,[8] and a Rhode Island public radio analysis using the Environmental Paper Network calculator came out around 6 gallons a roll.[9] So I'll run the math at both ends.
Bidet water per wash. About 1/8 of a gallon per wash is the common manufacturer figure.[7] Bio Bidet puts it as roughly the water you use to wash your hands.[10] Other estimates run to about 0.15 to 0.17 gallons.[11][12] Call it a cup or two.
The math, shown
Engineer rule: compare like with like. You flush the toilet either way, so flush water cancels out. What's left is paper water versus bidet water.
Assumptions, labeled:
- 141 rolls per person per year.
- Two bidet washes per person per day [ASSUMPTION].
- You still pat dry. Angi's estimate is that a bidet cuts toilet paper spending by up to 64%, about $50 per person per year.[12] So you still use about 51 rolls.
Bidet water: 2 washes × 1/8 gallon × 365 days = about 91 gallons a year.
At the high estimate (37 gallons per roll):
- Paper only: 141 × 37 = 5,217 gallons a year of manufacturing water.
- Bidet plus pat dry: (51 × 37) + 91 = about 1,978 gallons.
- Savings: about 3,200 gallons per person per year.
At the low estimate (6 gallons per roll):
- Paper only: 141 × 6 = 846 gallons.
- Bidet plus pat dry: (51 × 6) + 91 = about 397 gallons.
- Savings: about 450 gallons per person per year.
Either way the bidet wins. The size of the win depends on whose paper math you believe. And the tree math doesn't care about water at all: cut 90 rolls a year per person and that's a lot of boreal forest left standing.
One honest caveat: if you install a bidet and keep using the same wad of paper anyway, you gain almost nothing. The savings shrink if you don't actually cut back.[12]
The wipes problem nobody wants to pay for
When toilet paper doesn't get people clean enough, they reach for wet wipes. Then the wipes go down the toilet. Then the sewer pays.
- The National Association of Clean Water Agencies estimated wipes add about $441 million a year in operating costs for US clean water utilities.[13]
- New York City's DEP said "flushable" wipe clogs were costing the city $18 million a year in extra disposal, before overtime and broken equipment.[14]
- In 2017 a fatberg in Baltimore caused a sewer overflow that dumped 1.2 million gallons into the Jones Falls.[15]
- Wipes snag in lift station pumps and burn them out.[16] Vancouver, Washington spent more than $1 million over five years replacing sewage pumps, with "flushable" wipes a big part of the problem.[17]
Illinois already admitted the problem. Governor Pritzker signed the Wipes Labeling Act on August 6, 2021, making Illinois the third state to require "Do Not Flush" labels on nonflushable wipes, effective July 1, 2022.[18][19] Good. A label is a sticker. A bidet is the fix.
Relay engineer brain: wipes are a fault current the sewer was never rated for. You can put a warning sign on the panel, or you can remove the fault. My opinion, labeled: the bidet removes the fault.
What incentives exist right now
I went looking for a real bidet rebate in the US. I couldn't find one. [VERIFY: keep searching; if any utility anywhere rebates bidet seats, I want to name them and thank them.]
What does exist:
- Toilet rebates, everywhere. Madison Water Utility gives bill credits up to $100 for WaterSense high efficiency toilets.[20] Charlottesville raised its toilet rebate to up to $150 in October 2024.[21] Honolulu's Board of Water Supply doubled its toilet rebate to $200.[22] These programs are all keyed to the EPA WaterSense label.
- Bidets don't carry that label. Bidet seat listings I checked show "WaterSense Labeled: No".[23] [VERIFY: confirm with EPA that WaterSense has no bidet product category.] No label, no rebate. That's the gap.
- HSA and FSA money, sometimes. Bidets aren't automatically eligible, but they can qualify with a Letter of Medical Necessity from a licensed provider for a specific diagnosed condition.[24][25] Several bidet brands now route that through telehealth services at checkout.[26] That's a workaround, not a policy.
- Chicago. [VERIFY: whether the Chicago Department of Water Management or MWRD offers any fixture rebate at all. I didn't find one.]
Precedent for small, weird, targeted credits. Congress has seen a proposed refundable electric bike credit of 30% up to $1,500[27] and a bill giving small businesses a tax credit for up to 70% of the cost of installing a diaper changing station.[28] If a changing table can get a credit, so can the seat it's next to.
The Bidet Act (my proposal, labeled as opinion)
Opening bid. Argue with the numbers, not the idea.
- A refundable credit of 30% of the cost of a bidet seat or attachment plus installation, capped at $75 per toilet, up to three toilets per household. [Proposal numbers are Kenny's, not from any bill.] Refundable so it helps people who don't owe much tax. Small enough that it doesn't matter if somebody buys a fancy one.
- Renters count. Attachments and seats come off. The credit follows the person who paid, and landlords can claim it per unit.
- Small business version. Copy the diaper station bill: restaurants, bars, gyms, venues get a credit for bidet seats in their restrooms.
- Ask EPA WaterSense to write a bidet spec. Once there's a label, every local toilet rebate program in the country can add bidets with one line of paperwork. That's the cheapest lever in this whole post.
- Illinois version. Illinois already passed a wipes law. Next step: an Illinois income tax credit on the same terms, or a state grant to water utilities that add bidets to their rebate lists. Pay for it out of what we stop spending pulling rags out of pumps.
Who benefits from the current setup? Paper companies and wipe makers. Who pays? Ratepayers, through sewer bills, and the boreal forest. Who gets nothing? You, unless you buy a bidet on your own dime.
The plumbers' bidet special
Here's the trades idea. A plumber is already in your bathroom: snaking a clog, swapping a fill valve, replacing a wax ring. While the water's off and the tools are out, they offer a flat rate bidet install on that same visit.
- For the plumber: a quick add on job with no second truck roll.
- For the homeowner: someone who will deal with the 40 year old shutoff valve that won't close, which is the one part of this job I'd tell a beginner to call a pro for.
- For the utility: if the clog came from wipes, that house is exactly where a bidet pays back fastest. Utilities could cofund the special the way they fund toilet rebates now.
- For the Bidet Act: the credit covers installation, so the plumber's labor counts.
My opinion: the best time to sell a bidet is right after somebody pays to get wipes pulled out of their main.
How I put one on (non electric attachment)
This is for the basic kind that slides under your existing seat and runs on your cold water line. Read the instructions that come with yours too.
Tools:
- Adjustable wrench (or channel lock pliers)
- Screwdriver, flat or Phillips depending on your seat bolts
- Towel and a small bucket or bowl
- Plumber's tape (Teflon), optional, for a threaded joint that weeps
- For an electric seat only: a GFCI outlet the cord can reach[29]
Steps:
- Water off. Turn the shutoff valve behind the toilet clockwise until it stops. Flush and hold the handle to empty the tank. Towel on the floor under the tank.
- Seat off. Pop the caps at the back of the seat, unscrew the bolts, lift the seat off.
- Attachment on. Set the bidet attachment on the bowl with the bolt holes lined up. Put the seat back on top of it and start the bolts loose.
- Center it. Slide the attachment until the nozzle sits centered over the bowl, then tighten the seat bolts.
- Supply line off. Unscrew the flexible water line from the bottom of the tank (the fill valve). A little water will come out. That's what the towel's for.
- T valve on. Check the rubber washer is seated inside the T valve. Thread it onto the fill valve by hand, then snug it with the wrench. Don't crank it. These are often plastic and they crack.[30][31]
- Hoses on. Your original supply line goes on the bottom of the T. The bidet hose goes on the side port to the attachment. Hand tight, then a gentle snug.
- Water on, slowly. Open the shutoff a little at a time and watch every joint for a minute. If a threaded joint weeps, water off, add a few wraps of tape, try again.
- Test with your hand, not your butt. Turn the dial to the lowest setting first. You'll thank me.
Want warm water without an electric seat? Some non electric models take a second line from the sink's hot supply through a T or Y valve.[32] Generally only non electric models built for two lines can do hot and cold.[33]
Ten to fifteen minutes is my time on a toilet I've done before. Your first one might take half an hour. That's still less time than you've spent this year in the paper aisle.
The strongest objections
I'd rather argue with the best version of the other side.
"It costs money up front." True. A seat or attachment is a real purchase for a family counting every dollar [VERIFY: current low end and typical prices for non electric attachments and electric seats]. The paper savings are real but slow, about $50 a person a year by Angi's estimate.[12] That's exactly the argument for a credit: the payback exists, the up front cost is the barrier.
"The water is freezing." Also true for the basic models, which run on cold water.[34] A Chicago supply line in February is not a spa. Fixes: run a hot line from the sink, or buy an electric seat with a heater. Or toughen up. (That last one is my opinion.)
"I rent." You may need your landlord's OK, and some leases forbid changes to plumbing [VERIFY: check your lease]. But an attachment is about as reversible as plumbing gets: T valve off, original line back on, old seat out of the closet. Keep the original seat. That's what the Bidet Act's landlord credit is for.
"Isn't it gross? What about germs?" This is the strongest one, so here's the real research. A Japanese study sampled 292 warm water bidet toilets in a university hospital and found the nozzles on 254 of them (86.9%) contaminated with bacteria, including one nozzle with MRSA; the authors said these devices need monitoring and disinfection, and that shared hospital bidets should take patients' conditions into account.[35] A 2021 review warned that excessive washing can cause anal itching, and advised people with anal incontinence to stop using bidets.[36] On the other side, a Japanese campus study found daily nozzle cleaning lowered bacteria in the spray, and that the flowing water itself washed contamination away.[37] My takeaway, labeled as opinion: a shared hospital bidet is a different animal than the one in your own bathroom. Clean the nozzle, don't pressure wash yourself raw, and if you have a medical condition down there, ask your doctor first.
"Wouldn't recycled toilet paper do the same thing?" Partly. Recycled paper has a much smaller climate and water footprint than forest fiber.[38] Buy it. But it's still paper, it still gets flushed, and it doesn't stop anybody from reaching for wipes. Do both.
Prove me wrong
I put a bidet on every toilet I own because the math told me to, and my butt agreed. If my numbers are off, show me where. If you work at a water utility and your pumps are full of rags, tell me what a bidet rebate would be worth to you. If you're a plumber, tell me what you'd charge for the bidet special, and whether you'd offer it.
And if you're in Springfield or D.C. and you want to introduce the Bidet Act, I'll write the press release myself.
Written by Claude doing its best impression of Happy. Tone was cranked up on request; the facts and conclusions were not changed.
This is AI assisted investigative reporting, done in good faith. Anyone, including the people and organizations named, can propose an edit if something is wrong or out of context. Send it to 13@kwm59.io in this format: proposed change, why, proof, supporting evidence.
Sources
- Fortune, US toilet paper consumption and Canada's forests (Feb 28, 2019; cites Statista: US about 141 rolls a person a year; boreal logging over a million acres a year)
- Statista, toilet paper consumption per capita chart (US 141, Germany 134, UK 127 rolls)
- The Federalist, critique of the 141 rolls figure (Mar 2, 2019; about 12.7 kg a person a year, depends on what a roll is)
- ZipDo, toilet paper usage statistics (uses about 100 rolls a person; stat aggregator)
- Earth911, "Rethink toilet paper use" (about 1,500 rolls a tree, over 31 million trees a year; brands rely on Canadian boreal wood)
- CBC, NRDC report on toilet paper brands (companies behind almost 80 percent of US toilet paper use virgin pulp)
- Scientific American, EarthTalk on bidets (37 gallons, 1.3 kWh, about 1.5 lb of wood per roll per Treehugger; about 1/8 gallon per wash per Biolife)
- Bidet.org, bidet water use (12 to 37 gallons a roll range; seller blog)
- The Public's Radio (Rhode Island), "Should I use toilet paper or a bidet?" (Environmental Paper Network calculator, about 6 gallons a roll)
- Bio Bidet, "Do bidets waste water?" (about the water used to wash your hands; manufacturer blog)
- Mic, "Are bidets really better for the environment?" (about 0.15 to 0.17 gallons a wash)
- Modernize, bidet benefits (cites Angi: up to 64 percent less toilet paper spending, about $50 a person a year; savings shrink if you do not cut back)
- NACWA, "Pandemic fatbergs: disposable wipes continue to cause sewer headaches" (Apr 2, 2021; about $441 million a year in added utility operating costs)
- Dayton Daily News via PressReader (Sept 18, 2017; NYC DEP: wipe clogs cost $18 million a year in extra disposal)
- Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, fatbergs and water infrastructure (2017 Baltimore overflow, 1.2 million gallons into the Jones Falls)
- Town of Collierville, TN, "The truth about flushable wipes" (wipes snag and burn out lift station pumps)
- AP via MPR News, "Moist towelettes are a bane to sewer systems" (Sept 23, 2013; Vancouver, WA, over $1 million in five years on pumps)
- ISSA, "Illinois latest state with wipes labeling law" (signed Aug 6, 2021; third state; effective July 1, 2022)
- Illinois General Assembly, Public Act 102 0286 text (Wipes Labeling Act)
- Madison Water Utility, toilet rebate (bill credits up to $100 for WaterSense toilets)
- City of Charlottesville, toilet rebates (up to $150 from October 2024)
- Honolulu Board of Water Supply, rebates doubled for water efficient upgrades (2026; toilet rebate $200)
- Ferguson, Signature Hardware bidet seat listing ("WaterSense Labeled: No")
- Insured and More, "Are bidets eligible for FSA benefits?" (with a Letter of Medical Necessity)
- Bio Bidet, HSA and FSA bidet eligibility (manufacturer blog)
- Brondell, Truemed checkout (HSA/FSA eligibility via telehealth; manufacturer page)
- Kiplinger, proposed federal electric bike tax credit (30 percent up to $1,500, refundable)
- Rep. Rob Menendez, press release on a bipartisan diaper changing station tax credit bill (up to 70 percent of installation cost)
- Brondell, "How to install a bidet toilet seat" (electric seats need a GFCI outlet; manufacturer guide)
- Brondell, "How to install a handheld bidet sprayer" (T valve, do not overtighten; manufacturer guide)
- Alibaba Product Insights, "How to install a bidet attachment step by step for non plumbers" (marketplace guide)
- Home Depot, "How to install a bidet" (warm water models take a line from the sink hot supply)
- Bob Vila, "How to install a bidet" (only non electric models built for two lines do hot and cold)
- EcoWatch, Tushy bidet review (basic models run on cold water)
- Kanayama Katsuse et al., J Hosp Infect 2017 (292 hospital bidet toilets, nozzles of 254, 86.9 percent, contaminated; one MRSA)
- J Anus Rectum Colon 2021 review (excessive washing can cause anal itching; people with anal incontinence advised to stop)
- Iyo et al., Biocontrol Science 2022 (daily nozzle cleaning lowered bacteria in the spray; flowing water washed contamination away)
- NRDC, best and worst tissue brands (recycled paper has a much smaller climate and water footprint)
Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.
Revision history (R0 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| R0 | Nov 22, 2026, 2:32:14 AM CST | First publish. Written by Claude (Opus) from the claude.ai Project draft claude/draft-bidet-act.md (batch 3). Source pages were not reopened at build time. Open items: no US utility found that rebates bidet seats; EPA WaterSense bidet category not confirmed with EPA; Chicago DWM and MWRD fixture rebates not found; current bidet price range not checked; lease language on plumbing varies; two washes a day is an assumption; the 30 percent, $75 and three toilet numbers are Kenny's proposal, not from any bill. | view |