Church Air Rights in Chicago: Could Holy Name Cathedral Sell the Sky?
Chicago churches sit on land worth far more than their upkeep. The real deals, here and in New York, show what air rights can fund and where they stop.
What air rights are
When you own city land, you also own some right to build above it. Air rights are that right. City zoning limits how much a lot can hold, often as a floor area ratio, which divides total floor space by lot size. A low church on an expensive block leaves room unused. A transfer of development rights lets an owner sell that room to a neighbor. There is a catch: once an owner sells it, the height allowed on that site is capped for good.[3]
How Chicago handles it
Chicago has a different tool than New York. Since June 2016, downtown developers can pay the city for extra floor area. Most of that money goes to the Neighborhood Opportunity Fund, and only 10 percent goes to the Adopt a Landmark Fund for restoring landmarks.[1] So the bonus is not a way for a church to sell its own sky. Any project that uses the bonus also needs planned development review, a special zoning approval.[2]
A real Chicago test case is the Moody Church. In February 2023 it was reported to be planning to sell land and air rights to the developer Fern Hill, so a tower could rise on its parking lot at LaSalle Street and North Avenue. The plan needed City Council approval.[3] I could not confirm how it ended.
What Holy Name actually did
Holy Name Cathedral was dedicated in 1875 and is on the National Register of Historic Places.[8] In 2017 the Archdiocese of Chicago agreed to sell its parking lots, about 90,000 square feet at State Street and Chicago Avenue, to JDL Development for $110 million.[4][5] The lots are across the street from the cathedral, not beside it. This was a land sale, not an air rights sale. The money was meant for abuse victims, and it covered only a fraction of what the archdiocese owed.[5]
On that land rose One Chicago, two towers, the taller at 971 feet, with 735 apartments and 77 condominiums planned.[6] Housing arrived and the sanctuary was untouched.
The one Chicago church that did build into the sky is the Chicago Temple Building. It was finished in 1924 and rises 568 feet. The sanctuary is on the ground floor, offices fill floors 4 through 21, and a small Sky Chapel sits at the base of the steeple.[7]
What New York churches have done
In New York City, St. Bartholomew's Church wanted to replace a church owned building with an office tower. A federal appeals court ruled the city's Landmarks Law applied, and the Supreme Court refused to hear the case on March 4, 1991.[10][9] Decades later the church took the other route. It signed an option, reported in March 2024, to sell up to 250,000 square feet of air rights for up to $78 million, with court approval required.[11]
St. Patrick's Cathedral agreed to sell up to 525,000 square feet for between $98.4 million and $164 million, and its archdiocese said it hoped the money would go to upkeep.[13] The Church of St. Mary the Virgin agreed to sell its last 87,000 square feet to Extell for $23.93 million.[12] St. Thomas Church is in contract to sell 123,000 square feet for $36 million.[14] In each case the church stays put, and the tower rises next door.
Could Holy Name build above itself?
I found no sign that it has tried. The pattern in the real deals is a neighbor, not an overhead tower. A tower over a stone nave would need columns through old walls, legal agreements to protect worship and repair access, and city approvals, and parishioners would have to agree. The practical Chicago path looks like the Moody Church plan: move the capacity to a nearby lot, keep the sanctuary clear, and spend the proceeds on the roof. That is my read, not a ruling, and it would still go through planned development review.[2][3]
Sources
- City of Chicago, "Neighborhood Opportunity Bonus" (downtown developers pay for extra floor area; 80% Neighborhood Opportunity Fund, 10% Adopt a Landmark Fund, 10% Local Impact Fund; effective June 1, 2016)
- Chicago Zoning Ordinance, Chapter 17-8 Planned Developments, Sec. 17-8-0500 (planned development review required for any development using floor area bonuses under Sec. 17-4-1000, and for air rights over public ways)
- CoStar, Feb. 5, 2023, "Chicago Developer Aims for Rare Cooperative Approach to Securing Air Rights" (how air rights move between parcels; Moody Church plan with Fern Hill)
- Bisnow, April 5, 2017, "JDL Development To Buy Holy Name Cathedral Parking Lots For $110M" (90,000 square foot lot at State and Chicago, across from the cathedral)
- The Real Deal, Feb. 10, 2019, "Archdiocese of Chicago to use proceeds from land sale to pay sex abuse victims" ($110 million, agreed 2017, proceeds for abuse victims)
- Chicago YIMBY, One Chicago Square (two towers, 971 and 574 feet, 735 apartments and 77 condominiums planned, $850 million)
- Wikipedia, "First United Methodist Church of Chicago" (Chicago Temple Building, 1924, 568 feet, sanctuary on the ground floor, floors 4 through 21 rented as offices)
- Wikipedia, "Holy Name Cathedral (Chicago)" (dedicated Nov. 21, 1875; National Register of Historic Places, 2000)
- 499 U.S. 905 (1991), Rector, Wardens and Members of the Vestry of St. Bartholomew's Church v. City of New York (certiorari denied March 4, 1991)
- 914 F.2d 348 (2d Cir. 1990), St. Bartholomew's Church v. City of New York (church sought to replace a church owned building with an office tower; Landmarks Law applies)
- The Real Deal, March 7, 2024, "Ken Griffin agrees to $78M deal for more church air rights" (St. Bartholomew's option, up to 250,000 square feet, expires 2027, court approval)
- Commercial Observer, Oct. 2026, "Extell to Buy $24M in Air Rights From Episcopal Church for 570 Fifth Avenue Tower" (St. Mary the Virgin, $23.93 million, 87,000 square feet, filed for court approval)
- The Real Deal, Dec. 11, 2023, "Citadel agreed to buy air rights for 350 Park Ave office tower" (St. Patrick's Cathedral, $98.4 million to $164 million, up to 525,000 square feet)
- 6sqft, Nov. 17, 2025, "Extell to buy $36M in air rights from Midtown's St. Thomas church" (123,000 square feet, in contract, court approval needed)
Inspired by Happy. Prepared by Gemini (version unknown) and Perplexity (version unknown). Reviewed and edited by Claude.
Revision history (R1 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Nov 19, 2026, 9:08:14 pm CST (saved; chat message 9:08 pm) | What Gemini returned, unedited (version unknown, Thinking and Search on). Prompt handed out at 9:02:54 pm CST, so about five to six minutes. No citation markers at all, two UNSURE links. | view |
| D2 | Nov 19, 2026, 9:19:50 pm CST (saved; chat message 9:19 pm) | What Perplexity returned, unedited (version unknown), after the prompt went out at 9:14:11 pm CST. About five minutes. Every inline citation points to a private prison source. | view |
| R0 | Nov 19, 2026, 9:25:49 pm CST (reviewed and posted) | First publish, merged from D1 and D2 and edited by Claude. DeepSeek rerun is still pending and will be folded in later as D3 / R1. All citations rebuilt from pages opened this session; Holy Name lot moved from "beside" to across the street; St. Mary figure corrected to $23.93 million; added Chicago Temple, Moody Church, the Neighborhood Opportunity Bonus split and St. Bartholomew's $78 million option; cut unsourced claims. | view |
| R1 | Nov 22, 2026, 1:14:22 AM CST | Added a small QR code after the credit line that opens this post, so a photo of a screen can share it (Kenny asked, Nov 22). No text changed. Done by Claude (Opus) in one batch. | view |