Insect Farming as Food and Feed: What Is Real Today
Bugs were sold as the protein of the future. Most of them now go to chickens, fish and pets, and the biggest farm in the world went bust. Here is what holds up.
You're viewing revision R0 from Nov 19, 2026, 8:42:58 pm CST (reviewed and posted). See the current version.
Insect farming raises bugs such as crickets, mealworms and black soldier fly larvae for protein. Ten years ago it was sold as the food of the future. Today most of it ends up in chicken feed, fish feed and pet food, and some of the biggest farms have gone broke.[7]
How insect farming works
Insects are raised indoors in trays and climate controlled rooms. Black soldier fly larvae eat food scraps, manure or other organic matter and grow fast into fat, protein rich grubs.[1] The grubs are dried and ground into meal, which is protein powder, and pressed for oil.
Their droppings mixed with leftover food are called frass. It can be sold as fertilizer, and the EU wrote rules for it in 2021 that treat it like processed manure.[12] The main market is animal feed. The EU allowed insect protein in fish feed first, then in pig and poultry feed in 2021.[11]
The green claims are under review
The classic case for insects is strong on paper. Compared with livestock, they need less land and water, emit fewer greenhouse gases, and turn feed into body weight more efficiently.[2]
The catch is what they eat. Most farms do not feed them garbage. They feed them co products such as wheat bran and corn gluten, which livestock already eat, so the insects compete with cows and chickens for the same food.[7] A 2025 review in Biological Reviews argues the green benefits were overstated, and that insect protein made at scale was in most cases worse for the environment than the ingredients it replaces.[3][4] Industry figures said the review had inaccuracies.[5] Published footprints for black soldier fly protein run from about 0.5 to 77 kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent per kilogram of protein, depending on feed, energy and method.[6] That range is so wide that "insects are green" depends on how a given farm runs.
Where you can eat them
In the European Union, insects count as a novel food, which means they need safety approval before sale. Four species have it: the yellow mealworm, the migratory locust, the house cricket and the lesser mealworm, in forms such as frozen, dried and powder.[9][10] The first approval came in June 2021, and a UV treated mealworm powder followed in January 2025.[9][10]
Approval is not demand. One researcher who studies the industry put it flatly: the human food market "has not materialized."[7]
Why the big farms failed
Price is the wall. In 2023, insect meal cost US$3,800 to 6,000 a tonne. Fishmeal cost about US$1,815, and soybean meal about US$541.[8] That makes insect meal roughly 10 times the price of soy and 3.5 times the price of fishmeal.[7]
Investors put just under $2 billion into the sector by mid 2024.[14] The biggest bet was Ynsect, a French mealworm company that raised over $600 million.[7] A French court ordered it liquidated after a hearing on December 1, 2025.[13] Goterra, FarmInsect, AgriProtein and others also folded.[15] Companies that shut down now account for nearly half of all the money ever invested.[7]
So the honest picture is narrow. Insects can turn real waste into feed and fertilizer. As a cheap, green protein for people, they have not delivered yet.
Sources
- Wikipedia, "Black soldier fly" (larvae raised on organic waste for feed)
- van Huis and Oonincx, "The environmental sustainability of insects as food and feed. A review," Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 2017 (less land and water, lower emissions and higher feed conversion than livestock)
- Biteau, Bry Chevalier, Crummett, Loewy, Ryba and St. Jules, "Have the environmental benefits of insect farming been overstated? A critical review," Biological Reviews, Oct. 29, 2025
- FoodIngredientsFirst on the Biological Reviews study: insect protein at scale was in most cases less environmentally friendly than conventional ingredients
- The Grocer: UK insect farming industry figures criticised the review for inaccuracies
- Petfood Industry: Innovafeed and Protix paper, published black soldier fly assessments range from about 0.5 to 77 kg CO2 equivalent per kg of protein, and scale lowers the footprint (industry authors)
- Kenny Torrella, Vox via Mother Jones, March 12, 2026: insects mostly fed co products like wheat bran and corn gluten; insect meal about 10 times soybean meal and 3.5 times fishmeal; human food market "has not materialized"; shuttered startups hold nearly half of all investment; Ynsect raised over $600 million
- FAIRR, March 26, 2025: in 2023 insect meal cost US$3,800 to 6,000 a tonne, against US$1,815 for fishmeal and US$541 for soybean meal
- European Commission, "Approval of insect as a novel food": yellow mealworm, migratory locust, house cricket, lesser mealworm, and UV treated mealworm powder (Jan. 20, 2025)
- R Biopharm summary of EU insect food approvals with dates: mealworm June 2021, locust Nov. 2021, house cricket Feb. 2022, lesser mealworm and defatted cricket powder Jan. 2023
- International Animal Health Journal, 2026: insect processed animal proteins allowed in EU fish feed first, then in poultry and pig feed by Regulation (EU) 2021/1372, seven species including black soldier fly
- Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1925 of Nov. 5, 2021, which defines insect frass and sets rules for it like processed manure
- Global Pet Industry: the Evry commercial court ordered the judicial liquidation of Ynsect after a Dec. 1, 2025 hearing
- Rethink Priorities: just under $2 billion in disclosed investment in insect farming up to June 2024
- SeafoodSource, 2026: FarmInsect winds down; Insect Institute lists Goterra, Ynsect, Enorm, Aspire, Divaks, AgroLoop, BetaHatch and AgriProtein as failures (an advocacy group skeptical of insect farming)
Inspired by Happy. Prepared by Grok (version unknown). Reviewed and edited by Claude.
Next relatedTurning Landfill Plastic Into FuelRevision history (R0 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Nov 19, 2026, 8:37 pm CST (received) | What Grok returned, unedited (self report: Grok by xAI, version UNSURE, search on). Kept as the raw draft. Prompt handed out in an earlier session, time not recorded; received time is to the minute only. | view |
| R0 | Nov 19, 2026, 8:42:58 pm CST (reviewed and posted) | First publish, reviewed and edited by Claude (Opus). Added sources behind every claim (4 to 15); exact price figures (FAIRR, Vox); Ynsect liquidation date; the 2025 Biological Reviews review and the industry reply; EU feed and frass rules. Cut unsourced causes of failure. Sources read through search results; the review itself was not opened. | view |