Here is Happy's idea. If you own more than one home, you pick one as your residence within about a year. After a set number of years the others get bought out, "eminent domain or the like," so housing does not pile up in a few hands. Alongside it he wants more short stay housing, buses and trains that work the way they should, and a society that moves around more. In his words, "people should travel more." This post states the idea, checks it against real law and real policy, then gives the strongest case against it. It is not legal advice.

The law is not the wall people think it is

The Fifth Amendment lets government take private property for public use if it pays just compensation, which is what eminent domain means. In Kelo v. City of New London (2005), a 5 to 4 Court let a city take homes for an economic development plan, and added that nothing stops a state from setting tighter limits of its own.[1]

The closer match is older. In Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff (1984), Hawaii had a land oligopoly, so its legislature let people renting house lots ask the state to condemn the land under them and sell them the title. The Court upheld it, calling the breakup of concentrated ownership a legitimate public purpose.[2] That is very close to what Happy is describing.

The catch came after Kelo. Public anger was so strong that 45 states passed eminent domain reform laws.[3] Many now bar taking a home just to hand it to another private owner. A One Home Rule would have to get around those state laws, or be written state by state.

What cities actually tried: taxes, not takings

No city has forced a buyout of second homes. Several tax empty ones instead. Vancouver started its Empty Homes Tax in 2017. By the 2024 reference year the declared vacancy rate was 0.49 percent, down from 0.90 percent in 2017.[4] Those figures come from owners' own declarations.[5] The rate on an empty home is now 3 percent of its assessed value a year.[6]

Oakland, California charges a flat $3,000 or $6,000 per vacant property. Its auditor found about $29.8 million collected over six fiscal years, mostly spent on illegal dumping cleanup, with no baseline to show whether vacancy actually fell. The audit also said Proposition 13 limits are outside the city's control.[7] Washington, D.C. taxes occupied homes at $0.85 per $100 of value, vacant ones at $5.00, and blighted ones at $10.00.[8]

So the softer version of Happy's idea exists, and it nudges. It does not move ownership.

The strongest case against

It would hit smaller owners more than the rich. The US had about 6.2 million second homes in 2024, 4.3 percent of all housing.[9] On the rental side, the Census Bureau's 2024 survey found individuals, not companies, own 59.6 percent of single unit rentals.[10][11] Those individuals hold only about a third of all rental units, though, so the big apartment owners are mostly entities.[12] A rule aimed at people would catch the family with a rental duplex and miss the corporation with ten thousand units unless it covered companies too.

It would be enormously expensive. Just compensation means market price. At an assumed $300,000 per second home, a figure I picked to keep the math simple, buying all 6.2 million would cost close to $1.9 trillion before a single rental is counted.

Breaking up ownership did not fix prices in Hawaii. Critics of the Midkiff era say the transfers changed who held title without building new homes or making land cheaper.[15]

And the travel half has its own costs. A working paper on Airbnb found no substantial average rise in eviction filings when it arrived, but suggestive signs of a modest rise in poorer, renter heavy neighborhoods.[13] On trains, the Reason Foundation, a free market think tank, found an average subsidy of $109.85 per rider on eight Amtrak routes, while the bus route it compared ran at a profit.[14]

The honest reading: the Constitution is less of a barrier than people assume, and Midkiff proves the Court has gone there before. The barriers that remain are the price, the state laws written after Kelo, and the risk of hitting the small owner while the big one walks.

Sources

  1. Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005), opinion of the Court, June 23, 2005 (5 to 4; "nothing in our opinion precludes any State from placing further restrictions on its exercise of the takings power")
  2. Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff, 467 U.S. 229 (1984), syllabus and opinion, decided May 30, 1984 (Land Reform Act of 1967; redistributing title to reduce a land oligopoly is a rational use of eminent domain)
  3. State Court Report (Brennan Center), "Assessing the State Reaction to the Supreme Court's Undermining of Property Rights," 2025 (45 states passed eminent domain reform laws after Kelo)
  4. City of Vancouver, "Empty Homes Tax drives Vancouver's housing vacancies to record low," Dec 1, 2025 (0.49 percent in the 2024 reference year vs 0.90 percent in 2017; links the 2025 annual report)
  5. Castanet / The Canadian Press, "Empty homes tax debate swirls 10 years after pioneering tax in Vancouver" (vacancy rate is based on homeowner declarations; 979 vacant homes in 2024 per related coverage)
  6. City of Vancouver, Empty Homes Tax (homes declared or deemed empty in 2025 taxed at 3 percent of assessed value)
  7. Oakland City Auditor, press release on the Performance Audit of the Vacant Property Tax, July 10, 2026 (about $29.8 million collected FY2020-21 to FY2025-26, $26.8 million spent, two thirds on illegal dumping; flat $3,000 or $6,000; no vacancy baseline; Proposition 13 limits "outside the City's authority")
  8. DC Office of the Chief Financial Officer, Tax Rates and Revenues, Property Taxes (Class 1 residential $0.85 per $100, Class 3 vacant $5.00, Class 4 blighted $10.00)
  9. National Association of Home Builders, Eye on Housing, "Count of Second Homes Declines in 2024," April 2026 (6.2 million second homes, 4.3 percent of the housing stock; Florida 15.2 percent of the total; a builders' trade group)
  10. US Census Bureau, "Census Bureau Releases 2024 Rental Housing Finance Survey Summary Tables," Feb 19, 2026 (HUD sponsored, collected June to November 2024)
  11. GlobeSt, "Small Investors Still Dominate SFRs, Despite Institutional Buzz," Feb 25, 2026 (Chandan Economics reading of the 2024 RHFS: individuals own 59.6 percent of one unit rentals, down from 70.9 percent in 2021)
  12. HousingWire, "Small investors and housing supply" (2024 RHFS: individual investors own about 59 percent of rental properties but about 32 percent of rental units)
  13. Hannah Sayre, "Making Room for Vacationers? The Effect of Airbnb Entry on Eviction Filings in the United States," SSRN working paper (no substantial average increase in eviction filings; suggestive modest increase in high poverty and low owner occupancy tracts)
  14. Reason Foundation, "Comparing Amtrak and bus service in key corridors," from Jay Derr's Dec 2025 study (a free market think tank; average subsidy $109.85 per Amtrak rider on eight routes; the compared Greyhound route was profitable with no per passenger subsidy)
  15. Wikipedia, "Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff" (aftermath: critics say the transfers did not create new housing or lower prices; a tertiary source, used only for the aftermath)

Inspired by Happy. Prepared by DeepSeek (self reported, version unknown). Reviewed and edited by Claude.

Scan to open this post on your phone, or share it: kwm59.io/one-home-rule-housing-wealth-limit/
Next relatedSlab City and Earthships: What Garbage Can Build
Revision history (R1 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
D1Nov 20, 2026, 2:44:32 AM CST (logged on arrival; chat message 2:44 am, minute only)What DeepSeek returned, unedited (self report, version UNSURE, search on). Batch F prompt handed out Nov 20, 2:43:09 AM CST. About 1.5 minutes round trip.view
R0Nov 20, 2026, 3:54:16 AM CST (reviewed and posted)First publish, reviewed and edited by Claude (Opus). Added Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff and the 45 state post Kelo reforms, replaced the Oakland figure with the auditor's own, corrected the Airbnb eviction finding, added the NAHB second home count and the rental units nuance, labeled the think tanks, remapped markers; cut the DC progressive rate claim and the unused Oregon source.view
R1Nov 22, 2026, 1:14:22 AM CSTAdded a small QR code after the credit line that opens this post, so a photo of a screen can share it (Kenny asked, Nov 22). No text changed. Done by Claude (Opus) in one batch.view