Why I Would Refuse a Digital Dollar, and Why Stablecoins Are Not Private Either
Congress has now banned a Federal Reserve digital currency through 2030. The private dollar tokens that remain can freeze your money too.
You're viewing revision R0 from Nov 20, 2026, 2:57:04 AM CST (reviewed and posted). See the current version.
I would refuse a central bank digital currency, or CBDC. A CBDC is digital money that is a direct debt of the central bank itself, the way a paper dollar is, instead of a balance at your bank.[1] For the United States that means the Federal Reserve. My objection is simple. If the same institution issues the money and runs the ledger, it can see every payment, and depending on how it is built, it can block or freeze one. Those are design choices, not laws of nature. But I do not want my grocery money to depend on a system that is capable of watching it.
That is my position, not a description of America today. There is no US CBDC. And as of this summer, there cannot be one for a while.
Congress banned one, through a housing bill
The fight started in the White House. Executive Order 14178, signed January 23, 2025, ordered federal agencies to stop any CBDC work and barred them from establishing, issuing or promoting one, except where a law requires it. The same order says Americans have a right to keep self custody of their digital assets.[1] An executive order is policy, though. The next president can tear it up.
So Congress tried to make it law. The Anti CBDC Surveillance State Act passed the House on July 17, 2025, by 219 to 210, almost entirely along party lines.[2] It then sat in the Senate and never passed as its own bill.[3]
The ban got through another door. Senators wrote it into the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, a big bipartisan bill about housing supply. The Senate passed it 85 to 5 and the House 358 to 32 in June 2026.[4][5] President Trump refused to sign it, over an unrelated voting bill, but he did not veto it either. Under the Constitution, a bill left on the president's desk for 10 days while Congress is in session becomes law anyway. It did, on July 11, 2026.[6][7]
What the law does: the Fed and the regional Federal Reserve banks may not issue or create a CBDC, or anything "substantially similar," directly or through a bank, until December 31, 2030.[4] It does not touch banks or private companies building their own digital dollars, and private stablecoins are carved out.[8][9] Even after 2030 the Fed would still need Congress to say yes.[9] One law firm called the ban "largely confirmatory," since the Fed had already said it would not move without Congress.[6][7] Fair. But a promise and a statute are different things, and now it is a statute, with an expiration date.
The private digital dollar can freeze you too
Here is the part people miss. With the Fed shut out, the digital dollars Americans actually use are stablecoins: tokens issued by private companies and backed one to one by cash and Treasury bills. That sounds better for privacy. It is not automatically better.
Circle, the company behind USDC, can blacklist any address. Once it does, that address cannot send or receive USDC at all. Circle did this to about $100,000 on a law enforcement request back in July 2020, and to the addresses Treasury sanctioned in the Tornado Cash case in 2022.[12]
The GENIUS Act, the stablecoin law passed in July 2025, makes that power a requirement. A licensed issuer must have the technical ability to obey a lawful order to seize, freeze, burn or block the transfer of its coins.[10] A lawful order has to come from a court or an authorized federal agency and name the coins or accounts.[11] So there are rules. But the off switch exists by law. I covered this in more depth in What a Stablecoin Actually Is and Can It Be Seized?. Banning the government's digital dollar did not ban the freeze button. It moved it to a company.
What is actually private, and its limits
Cash still works. Hand someone a twenty and no ledger records it. But cash does not work online, and banks report cash deposits and withdrawals over $10,000.[15] (I argue about that rule in The Bank Secrecy Act: Charge Me or Let Me Go.)
Self custody means holding your own private keys, so no exchange or bank sits between you and your coins. Your wallet is your signature. It is also the idea behind my Privacy Server project. But it removes the custodian, not the issuer. If you hold USDC in your own wallet, Circle can still blacklist that address.[12] And self custody hides nothing on a public chain. Every Bitcoin transaction is public, traceable and stored forever.[13]
Privacy coins try to close that gap. Monero hides the sender, the receiver and the amount by default, using ring signatures and one time stealth addresses.[14] That is the closest digital thing to cash. It is also why some exchanges will not list it, and no tool promises perfect privacy against every kind of attacker.
The best case for a CBDC, and why I still say no
The other side deserves its due. A CBDC would be public money with no private company behind it, so no issuer could go bust. It could make payments faster and cheaper and reach people banks ignore. The Fed itself floated privacy protections and private middlemen between you and the central bank.
I still say no. Faster payments are worth having. A practical way to pay without being watched is worth more to me. The 2030 deadline means this argument comes back in four years, and I would rather have it settled now.
Scorecard: DeepSeek wins this one for getting the law right, even with scrambled citations. Perplexity had the better sources and the better manners, then cited prison reform articles on a money post and missed a law that had been on the books for four months.
Sources
- Federal Register, Executive Order 14178, "Strengthening American Leadership in Digital Financial Technology," Jan 23, 2025, published Jan 31, 2025 (CBDC defined as a direct liability of the central bank; agencies barred from establishing, issuing or promoting one except as required by law; self custody protected)
- Office of the Clerk, US House, Roll Call 201, H.R. 1919 Anti CBDC Surveillance State Act, July 17, 2025 (passed 219 to 210; 217 Republicans and 2 Democrats yes, 210 Democrats no)
- CryptoSlate, "Anti CBDC Surveillance State Act" law profile (H.R. 1919 passed the House, title later added to the House amendment to S. 1318 in April 2026, not enacted as of June 4, 2026)
- The Block, "Congress sends anti CBDC housing bill to Trump's desk for final approval," June 23, 2026 (House 358 to 32; ban on a Fed CBDC or any "substantially similar" digital asset through Dec 31, 2030)
- Cointelegraph, "Senate passes housing bill that includes a CBDC ban through 2030," June 2026 (Senate 85 to 5)
- The Block, "Housing bill that includes a CBDC ban passed into law without Trump's signature," July 11, 2026 (law after 10 days without a signature; the Fed had said it would not issue a CBDC without Congress)
- Cooley, "Key Financial Services Provisions in the ROAD to Housing Act," July 2026 (became law July 11, 2026; the CBDC ban is "temporary and largely confirmatory of existing policy")
- The Defiant, "Congress passes Fed CBDC ban through 2030," June 2026 (applies only to the Fed and Federal Reserve banks; does not restrict commercial banks or private companies building digital dollar products)
- Decrypt, "US Senate passes housing bill with Fed CBDC ban," June 2026 (carve out for private stablecoins; after 2030 the Fed would still need explicit authorization from Congress)
- Alston and Bird, "GENIUS Act Establishes Federal Regulatory Oversight of Global Stablecoin Industry," July 24, 2025 (issuers must be technologically capable of assisting with freezes, seizures and turnovers under lawful orders)
- Davis Polk, "GENIUS Act AML/CFT and Sanctions Compliance," Oct 2025 (a "lawful order" is a final order of a court or authorized federal agency requiring an issuer to seize, freeze, burn or prevent the transfer of its stablecoins)
- The Block, "Circle freezes USDC funds in Tornado Cash's US Treasury sanctioned wallets," Aug 2022 (a blacklisted address cannot receive or transfer USDC; about $100,000 frozen on a law enforcement request in July 2020)
- Bitcoin.org, "Protect your privacy" (all Bitcoin transactions are public, traceable and permanently stored in the network; DeepSeek did not cite it, Perplexity did)
- Monero Project, "What is Monero?" (ring signatures, ring confidential transactions and stealth addresses hide sender, receiver and amount)
- FinCEN, "Notice to Customers: A CTR Reference Guide" (banks report cash transactions over $10,000; structuring to avoid the report is a crime)
Inspired by Happy. Prepared by Perplexity (version unknown) and DeepSeek (version unknown). Reviewed and edited by Claude.
Next relatedWhat a Stablecoin Actually IsRevision history (R0 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Nov 20, 2026, 1:50:55 AM CST (logged on arrival; chat message 1:50 am, minute only) | What Perplexity returned, unedited (search on, version unknown). Batch D prompt handed out Nov 19, 9:23:36 PM CST. Body citations pointed at private prison articles; sent back. | view |
| D2 | Nov 20, 2026, 2:44:13 AM CST (logged on arrival; chat message 2:43 am, minute only) | What DeepSeek returned, unedited (search on, version unknown). Rerun prompt handed out 2:15:01 AM CST, so about 29 minutes round trip. Right about the ban becoming law; citations scrambled. | view |
| R0 | Nov 20, 2026, 2:57:04 AM CST (reviewed and posted) | First publish, merged from D1 and D2, reviewed and edited by Claude (Opus). Rebuilt every citation, sourced the law section from scratch (House clerk, The Block, Cointelegraph, Cooley, The Defiant, Decrypt), cut the unsupported privacy coin claim and the unconfirmed June 5 Senate vote, kept Perplexity's case for a CBDC. | view |