You're viewing revision R0 from 11/17/2026. See the current version.

In nuclear, every document had two names on it: the preparer and the reviewer. I learned fast which one mattered.

Preparers in line, a robot labeled AI, an intern and an engineer, each holding a paper, stopped at a gate. Past the gate a reviewer in a hard hat holds a stamp. Above, a qualification card: trained, qualified, independent. The manager checks the reviewer, not the work.

Anyone can prepare it

The federal rule for nuclear plant quality says the checking of a design "shall be performed by individuals or groups other than those who performed the original design" (10 CFR 50 Appendix B). Notice what it doesn't care about: who drafted it. An engineer, an intern, a contractor, a computer. The preparer is just the first draft.

The reviewer is the gate

The reviewer is independent, qualified, and signs. If it's wrong, it's on them. Engineers have the same idea with a professional engineer stamp. Courts do too: under Rule 11, a lawyer's signature certifies the filing was checked "after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances." In 2023, lawyers in Mata v. Avianca filed a brief full of cases ChatGPT made up. The court didn't fine ChatGPT. It fined the lawyers who signed, $5,000.

The manager's real job

A manager isn't there to check the work. That's the reviewer. The manager is closer to HR: making sure the person reviewing is trained, qualified and independent. In nuclear we called it a qual card.

Government and governance

Bills get drafted by staff, lobbyists, think tanks and soon AI. That's fine. The legislator who votes is the reviewer, and should answer for it. Same for a DAO: AI can prepare every proposal, but a qualified, named member signs off.

If AI ends up doing more of government and enforcement, the goal stays simple: comply with basic morals (most of the Ten Commandments still hold) and the agreements we've made. AI prepares and flags. A qualified human reviews and answers for it.

That's the whole idea behind WikiDuck: judge the work, and hold the reviewer accountable, not the preparer.

Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.

NextWikipedia Is Wrong. WikiDuck Is Right.
Revision history (R0 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
R011/17/2026First draft by Claude. Not yet reviewed.view