Should ICANN Be Dismantled? Who Controls Domain Names, and What Could Replace It
One private nonprofit in California sits over the internet's address book. The .org fight, the 2016 handover, blockchain names like ENS and Handshake, and the case for keeping one shared root.
Who keeps the address book
Every time you type a web address, your computer asks the Domain Name System, or DNS, the shared directory that turns names like kwm59.io into the number addresses computers use. At the top of that directory is the root zone, the master list of endings such as .com, .org and the country codes. The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, ICANN, coordinates that list. It is a private nonprofit public benefit corporation in California.[4] It also decides which new endings exist and accredits the companies that sell names.
For years the US government watched over it. The National Telecommunications and Information Administration, part of the Commerce Department, held the contract for the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority functions, the technical jobs behind the root.[1] On October 1, 2016 the government let that contract end.[2] Since then ICANN answers to its own community, not to any elected government.
Happy's case: one private board holds the switch
Happy's view is that the master switch of the world's naming should not sit inside one private corporation, and that ICANN should give way to open, decentralized protocols. The strongest evidence for his side is what ICANN can do with a single vote.
In November 2019 the Internet Society agreed to sell the Public Interest Registry, the nonprofit that runs .org, to the private equity firm Ethos Capital.[4] The price was $1.135 billion.[5] Charities feared fee hikes, since price caps on .org had been lifted that year, and US senators wrote to ICANN asking hard questions.[6] California's Attorney General told ICANN to reject the deal on April 15, 2020.[5] On April 30, 2020 ICANN's Board withheld its consent and the sale died.[4]
Most people cheered that result. But it proves Happy's point either way. A registry holding millions of names changed hands, or did not, on a vote of one board, nudged by one state.
The gate is also a toll booth. In April 2026 ICANN opened its first round of new endings in more than a decade, open until August 12, 2026.[7] The base fee to apply was $227,000 per ending, and that is a floor, not the full cost.[8] If you want your own ending on the shared internet, ICANN is the only door.
The blockchain alternatives, and where they break
Frustration with gatekeepers built blockchain naming systems, which record who owns a name on a public ledger instead of a company database. The Ethereum Name Service, ENS, lets people own .eth names through their crypto wallets.[9] {W("Handshake","https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handshake_(cryptocurrency)")} goes further and tries to replace the root itself, auctioning top level endings on its own blockchain.[10]
No board can take those names away. The catch is reach. Brave resolves .eth and some other blockchain names on its own.[11] Most mainstream browsers do not, because the names live outside ICANN's DNS, so visitors need an extension or a special resolver.[12] Lose your private key and the name is gone, with no one to call.
The most telling fact cuts against the rebels. Brave and Unstoppable Domains, which built .brave as a blockchain ending, said they were exploring an ICANN application for it so it would work everywhere.[12] Even the alternatives want into the root. ENS itself argues it already does what the new ICANN endings promise, but it is an interested party.[13]
The strongest case for keeping ICANN
The internet works worldwide because every computer agrees on one root. If two systems hand the same name to two owners, which is called a name collision, traffic and payments can go to the wrong place. Tear down the one root without a single replacement and the web could split into islands where a site works in one browser or country and not another.
ICANN is also not as unchecked as it looks. The 2016 handover gave its community legal powers: reject ICANN's budget, remove individual directors, even recall the entire Board.[3] The US would only let go if the replacement was not run by governments.[1]
So the honest answer is narrower than "dismantle it." One shared root is worth keeping. One private board deciding who gets to run .org, and charging six figures to ask for a new ending, is worth fighting. The blockchain projects are the pressure that keeps that question alive.
Sources
- National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Fact Sheet on NTIA's Assessment of the IANA Stewardship Transition Proposal, June 9, 2016 (Gemini source 1; not opened here)
- NTIA, Quarterly Report on the IANA Functions Stewardship Transition, Q4 FY2016, Oct 24, 2016 (Gemini source 2; the contract expired and the transition completed Oct 1, 2016; not opened here)
- ICANN, The Empowered Community (nine community powers, including rejecting ICANN and IANA budgets, removing individual directors and recalling the whole Board)
- ICANN, Minutes, Special Meeting of the ICANN Board, April 30, 2020 (resolution withholding consent to PIR's change of control; ICANN is a California nonprofit public benefit corporation; ISOC and Ethos deal announced Nov 13, 2019)
- Domain Name Wire, "ICANN rejects .org sale to private equity company," April 30, 2020 (deal price $1.135 billion; California Attorney General Xavier Becerra urged rejection April 15, 2020)
- Letter from Sen. Elizabeth Warren and others to ICANN leadership on the proposed sale of PIR, March 18, 2020 (Gemini source 5; not opened here)
- ICANN, "ICANN Opens Application Window for New Generic Top-Level Domains," April 30, 2026 (2026 Round open until Aug 12, 2026; first new round in more than a decade)
- Dynadot, "ICANN New gTLD Program 2026" (registrar blog; base evaluation fee $227,000 per application, a floor, not the full cost)
- Ethereum Name Service, Documentation FAQ (Gemini source 6; .eth names owned through Ethereum accounts)
- Handshake, project site (a decentralized naming protocol that aims to replace the root zone; not opened here, described from the project's own claims)
- Brave, "Brave Crypto DNS Strategy" (Brave resolves ENS .eth, Unstoppable Domains and Solana Name Service names; ENS on desktop and Android)
- The Block, "Brave becomes first major web browser to introduce its own onchain domain," May 21, 2025 (blockchain domains do not resolve universally in mainstream browsers because they sit outside ICANN's DNS; Brave and Unstoppable Domains exploring an ICANN gTLD for .brave in 2026)
- Ethereum Name Service, "ENS Already Does What Every .Whatever Is Trying to Do," March 5, 2026 (Gemini source 7; ENS's own position, an interested party)
Inspired by Happy. Prepared by Gemini (self reported, version unknown). Reviewed and edited by Claude.
Next relatedCan It Be Seized?Revision history (R0 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Nov 20, 2026, 3:07:43 AM CST (logged on arrival; chat message 3:07 am, minute only) | What Gemini returned, unedited (self report, version UNSURE, thinking and search on). Batch G prompt handed out Nov 20, 3:04:20 AM CST, meant for DeepSeek. About 3 minutes round trip. | view |
| R0 | Nov 20, 2026, 3:24:25 AM CST (reviewed and posted) | First publish, reviewed and edited by Claude (Opus). Labeled the dismantle view as Happy's, fixed the browser and government claims, added the $1.135 billion price, the California AG letter, the 2026 new endings round and its fee, and the Brave .brave example; dropped the LearnHNS blog. | view |