D1: what Gemini returned
Unedited, before any fact check. Kept for the record.
This is D1, the raw draft from Gemini, exactly as returned. It has errors that were fixed in the final article. Read the final article.
MODEL: Gemini by Google, version UNSURE (Thinking mode: on, Search mode: on) SLUG: should-icann-be-dismantled TITLE: Should ICANN Be Dismantled? Who Controls Domain Names and the Alternatives META_DESC: A look at ICANN, the 2016 IANA transition, the blocked .org sale, blockchain naming alternatives like ENS and Handshake, and whether ICANN should be replaced.
Who Really Controls the Address Book
Every time you type a web address, your computer consults the Domain Name System, the global directory that translates human names into numerical network addresses [1]. That master directory is coordinated by the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, known as ICANN, a private nonprofit based in California [2]. ICANN oversees the root zone, which is the top list of approved domain endings such as .com, .org, and country codes, and accredits the companies that sell names to the public [1, 3].
In my view, placing the master switch of global internet naming inside a single private corporation gives it far too much unaccountable power, and ICANN should be dismantled in favor of open, decentralized protocols. For years, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, an agency of the United States government, supervised those root functions under contract [2]. On October 1, 2016, the government allowed that contract to expire, completing the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority stewardship transition [2]. Since that date, ICANN has answered to its own internal multistakeholder boards rather than any elected government [2].
Controversies Over Power and Public Trust
Critics argue that ICANN operates like an unchecked regulator that favors big registry operators over everyday users. In 2019, the Internet Society agreed to sell the Public Interest Registry, the nonprofit manager of the .org domain, to a private equity firm called Ethos Capital for more than one billion dollars [4, 5]. Because ICANN had recently lifted price caps on .org registrations, charities and civil society groups feared steep fee hikes and opaque ownership [5]. Following fierce public backlash and warnings from state officials, the ICANN board voted in April 2020 to withhold consent and block the transfer [4]. While the deal failed, the episode showed how one board holds life or death power over major parts of the web [4, 5].
Blockchain Naming and Its Limits
Frustration with central gatekeepers has inspired blockchain naming systems, which store domain ownership on shared public ledgers rather than central databases [3]. The Ethereum Name Service, or ENS, lets users register .eth names tied to cryptocurrency wallets and decentralized websites [3, 6]. Another project, Handshake, attempts to replace the ICANN root zone itself by auctioning top level domains directly on a public blockchain [3].
These tools stop a central board from seizing a name, yet they carry serious weaknesses [3, 6]. Standard web browsers do not resolve .eth or Handshake addresses natively, forcing visitors to install special plugins or custom resolvers [3]. Worse, inventing new top level endings outside ICANN creates namespace collisions, meaning two separate networks can assign the exact same domain string to different owners and misdirect traffic or payments [7]. Losing a private cryptographic key also means losing a domain forever with no customer support [6].
The Strongest Case for Keeping ICANN
Defenders of ICANN make a compelling practical argument. The internet works worldwide because every computer looks up names in one shared, reliable root [1, 7]. Breaking ICANN apart without a universal replacement risks splitting the web into incompatible islands where a website works in one country or browser and fails in another [7]. Furthermore, the 2016 transition added community powers allowing stakeholders to veto budgets or remove board members, while keeping authoritarian governments from seizing control of global domain rules [1]. Even so, universal lookup should not require permanent rule by a single corporate gatekeeper, and building open, interoperable standards remains the healthier long term goal.
Links and sources as returned
LINKS_CHECK: ```text Domain Name System | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_Name_System Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICANN National Telecommunications and Information Administration | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Telecommunications_and_Information_Administration Internet Assigned Numbers Authority | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Assigned_Numbers_Authority Internet Society | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Society Public Interest Registry | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Interest_Registry Ethos Capital | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethos_Capital blockchain | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockchain Ethereum Name Service | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum_Name_Service Handshake | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handshake_(cryptocurrency) ``` SOURCES: ```text 1. National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Fact Sheet on NTIA's Assessment of the IANA Stewardship Transition Proposal, June 9, 2016, https://www.ntia.gov/other-publication/fact-sheet-ntia-s-assessment-iana-stewardship-transition-proposal 2. National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Quarterly Report on the Transition of the Stewardship of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) Functions Q4 FY2016, October 24, 2016, https://www.ntia.gov/sites/default/files/publications/final_ntia_iana_8th_quarterly_report_q4_fy_2016_0.pdf 3. LearnHNS, Handshake vs ENS vs Unstoppable Domains, June 15, 2026, https://learnhns.com/blog/handshake-vs-ens-vs-unstoppable-domains-2026/ 4. Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, ICANN Board Withholds Consent for a Change of Control of the Public Interest Registry (PIR), April 30, 2020, https://www.icann.org/en/blogs/details/icann-board-withholds-consent-for-a-change-of-control-of-the-public-interest-registry-pir-30-04-2020-en 5. United States Senate Correspondence via ICANN, Letter from Senator Elizabeth Warren et al to ICANN Leadership on Proposed Sale of PIR, March 18, 2020, https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/correspondence/warren-et-al-to-marby-et-al-18mar20-en.pdf 6. Ethereum Name Service, ENS Documentation FAQ, 2026, https://docs.ens.domains/faq/ 7. Ethereum Name Service, ENS Already Does What Every .Whatever Is Trying to Do, March 5, 2026, https://ens.domains/blog/post/ens-was-here-first ```