You're viewing revision R0 from 11/17/2026. See the current version.

The Ten Commandments weren't wrong. A few of them are just highly opinionated.

If God is an idea, as I've argued in God Is Only an Idea, then the commandments are ideas too: rules people wrote for living together. An idea can still be a good one. So let's sort them.

Two stone tablets. Commandments I to IV have yellow sticky notes reading opinion, opinion, strong and day off fine; V to X have green check marks

Opinionated: I to IV

One god only. No idols. Don't take the name in vain. Keep the Sabbath. These are about loyalty to one god: fine if that's your god, a preference if it isn't. The Sabbath gets partial credit. A day off is one of humanity's best ideas. We call it the weekend.

Still solid: V to X

Honor your parents. Don't murder. Don't cheat on your partner. Don't steal. Don't lie about people. Don't covet what's theirs.

Most of those are still the law, and the rest are good manners. Even the last one, coveting, is the envy from Why Would Anyone Steal?: the one bug a perfect society can't patch.

Six out of ten still hold up after thousands of years. That's a better record than most laws.

Jewish, Catholic and Protestant traditions number them differently. I'm using the common Protestant order.

Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.

NextLove Is an Integral
Revision history (R0 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
R011/17/2026First draft by Claude. Not yet reviewed.view