You're viewing revision R0 from Nov 17, 2026. See the current version.

My father does not call to lecture. He sends songs. Two of them, on repeat, for years. "Simple Man" by Lynyrd Skynyrd and "Carry On Wayward Son" by Kansas. I know exactly what both of them mean. They are his way of saying, son, you are headed the wrong way. Slow down. Come home. Keep your head down and you will find your peace.

He comes by it honestly. His own father worked the line at Ford and kept a cabin up north. One paycheck carried a whole family. You showed up, you did the work, you did not make noise, and the deal held up its end, with a pension waiting at the finish. That was not naive. For his time it was simply true.

The deal those songs describe is gone

Here is the part that is hard to say to your dad. The arrangement that rewarded keeping your head down does not really exist anymore. The pension that anchored it has nearly vanished. The share of private sector workers with a traditional defined benefit pension fell from 38 percent in 1979 to 11 percent by 2017, a drop of about 71 percent. The thing that made loyalty pay off at the end got quietly cancelled.

One income does not stretch the way it used to either. Elizabeth Warren's "two income trap" argument is that it now takes two paychecks to buy what one bought a generation ago, a house in a safe neighborhood with a decent school. You can argue the economics all day, but the shape is clear enough: two earners is the default now, divorce is ordinary, and the single breadwinner nuclear family my grandfather would recognize is not really on the menu.

His way was not wrong. It just is not available.

That is the thing I want him to hear. "Simple Man" was not bad advice in 1973. "Carry On Wayward Son" is not wrong that there is rest at the end of the road. The trouble is that the path those songs point down was paved for a world that has since been torn up. Telling me to walk it is a little like handing me a map to a town that got flooded. The roads are right where the map says. The town is underwater.

So maybe the peace he wants for me does not come from settling down the way he did. Maybe it comes from the newer version of the same thing: finding your own people instead of the ones you were assigned, and your own work instead of the job that was supposed to last forty years. I think he would actually recognize that, if we could get past the cassette tapes. He is not wrong that I am looking for peace. We just disagree about the address.

Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.

Revision history (R0 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
R0Nov 17, 2026First published.view