Why Would Anyone Steal in a Perfect Society?
If everything's free, what's left to take?
You're viewing revision R0 from 11/17/2026. See the current version.
Picture it. Rent is covered, there's food on every table, a ride to anywhere and a couch in every town. Would anyone still steal?

Probably. Need is only one reason people take things. Here's how the rest hold up:

A perfect society can fix need and maybe grievance. The rest live inside people: wanting what's yours because it's yours, the rush of getting away with it, and kleptomania, a real disorder that needs care, not cops. Then there's Proudhon, who argued in 1840 that property itself is theft.
So flip the question
Maybe a perfect society isn't one where nobody would steal. It's one where the things that matter can't be stolen. Nobody can take your skills, your friendships, your reputation or the people who'd vouch for you. Make those the real wealth and the raccoon can have the TV.
That's also the answer to the off switch in Can It Be Seized? The less there is worth stealing, the less anyone needs a switch.
Inspired by Happy, written by Claude.
NextThe Ten Commandments Weren't WrongRevision history (R0 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| R0 | 11/17/2026 | First draft by Claude. Not yet reviewed. | view |