Nissan.com: How Uzi Nissan Kept His Own Name From Nissan Motor
A North Carolina computer shop owner registered his surname in 1994. The carmaker sued for $10 million and never got the domain. What the courts actually decided, what it cost him, and how domain fights work now.
In 1994 a computer shop owner in North Carolina registered his last name as a web address. His name was Uzi Nissan, and the address was nissan.com. Five years later Nissan Motor sued him. He kept the domain until he died. The fight shows where a trademark ends and a person's own name begins.
One name, two businesses
Uzi Nissan had used his surname in business since 1980, starting with a car repair service. He founded Nissan Computer Corp. in 1991 and registered nissan.com on June 4, 1994.[1] The carmaker had registered NISSAN as a trademark in 1959, but in the United States it sold cars as {W("Datsun","https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datsun")} until 1983 and dropped that name only in 1985.[1]
In August 1999 Nissan Computer put banner ads on the site and earned money per click. Car ads showed up in late September. Nissan Motor sued on December 10, 1999.[1] It asked for $10 million.[4]
What the courts decided
The case is Nissan Motors v. Nissan Computer. On August 6, 2004 the Ninth Circuit gave each side part of a win.[1]
On infringement, the carmaker won, but only on car ads. The court used initial interest confusion, the idea that a site trades on a brand when it grabs people who came looking for that brand, even if they figure it out later. People typing nissan.com to find cars and landing on car ads fit that. His computer business did not.[1]
On trademark dilution, which protects famous marks even without confusion, Nissan Motor lost its win. The law asked whether the mark was famous before his first use. The court said that first use was 1991, when Nissan Computer started, not 1994, when he got the domain. Whether the mark was famous in 1991 was a real question, so it went back for trial.[1][2]
The lower court had also barred him from linking to pages criticizing the carmaker. The appeals court struck that down under the First Amendment. Criticism is not commercial speech just because it could hurt a company.[1]
Nissan Motor asked the Supreme Court of the United States to take the case. It said no in 2005.[3] The case ended with a final judgment in September 2007, after the carmaker dropped its $10 million damages claim before a jury trial. The domain stayed with Uzi Nissan.[4]
What winning cost
By June 2002 he said he had spent about $2.2 million and that the case had ruined his business and his marriage.[5] By the end he put the cost near $3 million and called it a weary victory, saying it drove him almost all the way out of business.[4]
He died in 2020 of COVID-19.[7] In 2023 his estate sued in federal court in Virginia, saying someone got into his registrar account without permission and moved nissan.com and nissan.net.[6] On April 16, 2024 a judge granted a default judgment, a ruling against a side that never shows up to defend, and ordered both domains returned to the estate.[7] That was a theft case. The carmaker was not part of it.
How a fight like this goes now
Most domain fights today never reach a courtroom. ICANN adopted the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy in 1999. A brand owner has to prove three things: the domain matches or is confusingly close to its mark, the holder has no right or legitimate interest in it, and it was registered and used in bad faith. Being commonly known by the name, or using it for a real business before any dispute, counts as a legitimate interest. A panel can only cancel or transfer the domain, not award money, and either side can still go to court.[8]
Uzi Nissan checks almost every box on the holder's side: his real name, a real business, years before any complaint. Even so, his name did not cover car ads. The lesson is narrower than "your name always wins." You can keep your own name. You cannot use it to sell the other company's product.
Sources
- Nissan Motor Co. v. Nissan Computer Corp., 378 F.3d 1002 (9th Cir. Aug 6, 2004), via Justia (official copy: https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2004/08/06/0257148.pdf). Facts: Uzi Nissan's businesses since 1980, Nissan Computer 1991, nissan.com June 4, 1994, banner ads Aug 1999, auto ads late Sept 1999, suit Dec 10, 1999, Datsun to Nissan 1983 to 1985. Holdings: initial interest confusion for auto related use only; fame measured as of 1991, dilution reversed and remanded; injunction on links to disparaging comments violates the First Amendment
- Public Citizen, "U.S. Court of Appeals Upholds Right to Criticize Nissan Motor," Aug 6, 2004 (case sent back for a jury trial on whether the mark was famous in 1991)
- Pinsent Masons Out-Law, "Supreme Court rejects Nissan.com appeal," Apr 20, 2005
- Jalopnik, "Uzi Nissan Spent 8 Years Fighting The Car Company With His Name," Feb 22, 2018 ($10 million suit; nearly $3 million cost by his account; Sept 2007 final judgment after Nissan Motor dropped its damages claim; "a weary victory")
- Salon, "Nissan vs. Nissan," June 3, 2002 (about $2.2 million spent so far; "ruined my business and my marriage")
- The Drive, "Lawsuit Claims Nissan.com Has Been Stolen After Years of Legal Drama," Nov 1, 2023 (estate's 2023 federal suit in Virginia; alleged unauthorized access to the GKG.net account)
- Domain Name Wire, "Judge orders Nissan.com transferred back to estate of Uzi Nissan," Apr 17, 2024 (default judgment Apr 16, 2024; nissan.com and nissan.net; Uzi Nissan died in 2020 of COVID-19)
- ICANN, Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy, adopted Aug 26, 1999 (paragraph 4(a) three elements, 4(c) legitimate interests, 4(i) remedies, 4(k) courts)
Inspired by Happy. Prepared by Perplexity (version unknown) and DeepSeek (version unknown). Reviewed and edited by Claude.
Revision history (R0 current)
| Rev | Date | What changed | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Nov 22, 2026, 3:20:53 AM CST (saved on arrival; chat message 3:20 am, minute only) | What Perplexity returned, unedited (self report, version unsure). Its chat app turned every citation into an ssa.gov link. Batch M prompt handed out Nov 22, 3:05:31 AM CST (also handed out earlier since Nov 19). | view |
| D2 | Nov 22, 2026, 3:20:53 AM CST (saved on arrival, same paste) | What DeepSeek returned, unedited (self report, version unsure). Markers ran past its source list; wrong fame date. | view |
| R0 | Nov 22, 2026, 3:35:17 AM CST (reviewed and posted) | First publish, merged from D1 and D2, reviewed and edited by Claude (Opus). Law from Perplexity, color from DeepSeek, citations rebuilt from the opinion and news sources, 2007 ending added. | view |