You're viewing revision R0 from Nov 19, 2026, 9:19:32 pm CST (reviewed and posted). See the current version.

What happened

In 1981, photographer Lynn Goldsmith shot portraits of Prince. In 1984, Vanity Fair paid her $400 to license one photo as an "artist reference" for a single illustration.[2][4] The artist was Andy Warhol. He did not stop at one. He made sixteen works from that photo, silkscreens and drawings in his bright, hard outlined style.[3]

Warhol died in 1987. When Prince died in 2016, Conde Nast put one of those images, Orange Prince, on a tribute magazine cover. It paid the Andy Warhol Foundation $10,250. Goldsmith got no credit and no money, so she pushed back, and the case ended up in court.[2]

How the Court ruled

The Supreme Court decided it on May 18, 2023, 7 to 2 for Goldsmith.[1][4] Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that the 2016 license was not fair use, the rule that lets people use a work without permission for things like comment, criticism or teaching. Both the photo and the Warhol were doing the same job, a picture of Prince sold to a magazine, and the new colors did not change that purpose.[1]

The ruling was narrow. The Court judged the 2016 licensing, not whether the paintings themselves were legal, and only the first fair use factor, the purpose of the use, was in front of it.[3][5] Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, dissented and warned it would chill new art.[5] In 2024 the foundation settled with Goldsmith for about $21,000.[6]

What it means for remakes

A derivative work is a new work built on an old one: a translation, a remix, a painting made from a photo. The owner of the original controls those, unless the new use is fair.[1][9]

So a new color on someone else's picture is not automatically a new work. A filter is not a defense. What matters is whether the new piece does a different job and does not take the original's place in its market.[1] Comment, parody and teaching can still be fair. Selling a recognizable copy for the same use the original sells for is the hard case, and Warhol lost it. It is the same argument I made about Banksy and about Metallica and Pixel Grip: the artist decides what is free.

AI "in the style of"

Style itself is not owned. Anyone can paint like someone else, and an AI can help. A prompt asking for a photographer's style is different from an output that reproduces one of her actual frames.

The U.S. Copyright Office said as much in 2025. Its report on AI training leans on Warhol to say that being transformative is a matter of degree.[7] It called training on a large, varied dataset often transformative, but warned about outputs that closely resemble the works the model learned from.[8] An output that stands in for a licensed image faces the same question Warhol did.

Respecting artists is simple in practice. Use the official release or pay for a license. Borrow ideas freely. Do not sell a copy with a fresh coat of paint and call it new. That is the idea behind Two of Five: official, numbered pieces from the artist, and free ones only where the artist says so.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of the United States, Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, No. 21-869, opinion, May 18, 2023
  2. HFG, 2023 (1981 photo; $400 license in 1984; Conde Nast paid the foundation $10,250 for the 2016 cover; Goldsmith got no credit or payment)
  3. Associated Press via KTTC, May 18, 2023 (16 works from one photo; only the first fair use factor was before the Court)
  4. The Fader, May 18, 2023 (7 to 2 for Goldsmith; Vanity Fair licensed the photo as an "artist reference")
  5. The Daily Record, May 18, 2023 (the ruling covers the 2016 publication; the dissent said it would stifle art)
  6. Artforum, 2024, the Warhol Foundation settles with Goldsmith for about $21,000
  7. Sidley Austin, May 28, 2025, on the U.S. Copyright Office's Part III report on generative AI training (relies on Warhol: transformative use is a matter of degree)
  8. Osha Bergman Watanabe & Burton, 2025 (the Copyright Office says training is often transformative but warns about outputs that closely resemble the originals)
  9. Wikipedia, "Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith" (from the DeepSeek draft)

Inspired by Happy. Prepared by DeepSeek (version unconfirmed). Reviewed and edited by Claude.

Next relatedMy Supreme Court QR Code vs a Banksy: Which Lasts?
Revision history (R0 current)
RevDateWhat changedPage
D1Nov 19, 2026, 9:07 pm CST (received, minute only; logged 9:07:58 pm)What DeepSeek returned, unedited (self report deepseek-flash, version UNSURE, search on). Prompt handed out at 9:02:54 pm CST, so about four to five minutes.view
R0Nov 19, 2026, 9:19:32 pm CST (reviewed and posted)First publish, reviewed and edited by Claude (Opus). Added the opinion, the dollar figures ($400, $10,250, about $21,000 settlement) and the Copyright Office AI report; replaced two Wikipedia sources; linked Banksy, Metallica and Two of Five. Sources checked through search results.view